Old-Fashioned

Filter
46 products
Best sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
Type
Flavor
Out of stock
Sort by
Abba Zabba
$2.50
Sold out
Anise Squares
$4.99
Assorted Fruit Gems
$4.99
Assorted Fruit Slices
$4.99
Assorted Rods
$4.99
Assorted Sour Tootsie Roll
$4.99
Assorted Tootsie Roll
$4.99
Atomic Fireballs
$4.99
Sold out
Bali's Coffee Candy
$4.99
Banana Split
$4.99
Sold out
Big Hunk
$2.50
Sold out
Bit-O-Honey
$4.99
Bit-O-Honey Bar
$1.50
Sold out
Bonomo Turkish Taffy
$2.00
Boston Baked Beans
$4.99
Botan Rice Candy
$2.50
Butterscotch Button
$4.99
Chick-O-Stick
$4.99
Chocolate Bullseye
$4.99
Sold out
Chocolate Caramel
$4.99
Chocolate Cherry Caramel Nougats
$4.50
Sold out
Dubble Bubble
$4.99
Dutch Mints
$4.99
Sold out
Extreme Sour Cry Babies
$4.99
French Burnt Peanuts
$4.99
Hopjes
$4.99
Horehound Lumps
$4.99
Hot Tamales
$4.99
Jordan Almonds
$4.99
Lemon Heads
$4.99
Look Bar
$2.50
Sold out
Mary Janes
$4.99
Neopolitan Coconut Slice
$2.50
Old-Fashioned Taffy
$1.99
Orange Slices
$4.99
Peanut Butter Bars
$4.99
Rootbeer Barrel
$4.99
Sea Salt Vanilla Caramel
$4.50
Sesame Honey Crunch
$4.99
Smarties
$4.99
Sour Lemon Drops
$4.99
Sugar-Free Chick-O-Stick
$4.99
Sold out
Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Bars
$4.99
Tootsie Roll
$4.99
Vanilla Bullseye
$4.99
Sold out
Vanilla Caramel
$4.99